The 2004 record
On March 30, 2004, legislators held a public hearing at Skylands Manor in Ringwood on the bill that became the Highlands Act. 45 people gave substantial testimony: environmental groups, residents, town officials and others. Whatever they thought of the bill, many raised the same question: who pays for the cost of protection.
Supported the bill (17)
Jennifer Mattice — New Jersey Audubon Society
Jennifer Mattice from the New Jersey Audubon Society supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act to preserve the 400,000 acres of critical core habitat in the Highlands, emphasizing the need for a development freeze and strong legislation to protect endangered species and drinking water supplies.
“We’re here to say that we think that it’s important that we preserve this core area of the Highlands, which strong legislation is needed to preserve the 400,000 acres of critical core habitat.”transcript p. 14
Dennis W. Schvejda — Conservation Director
Dennis Schvejda, Conservation Director for the New Jersey Chapter of the Sierra Club, strongly supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act to prevent overdevelopment and protect water supply and quality in the Highlands region.
“That’s really the future for the Highlands unless this legislation passes.”transcript p. 16
Patty Whitehouse — Legislation/Resolutions Chairman; New Jersey State Federation of Women’s Clubs of GFWC
Patty Whitehouse, representing the New Jersey State Federation of Women's Clubs, strongly supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the need for permanent preservation of the Highlands region to protect its vital water supply.
“The New Jersey State Federation of Women’s Clubs, a defender of the environment for more than 100 years, strongly supports the recommendations made by the Highlands Task Force and urges both Committees not to weaken those recommendations.”transcript p. 24
Karen Vernon — League of Women Voters of Ringwood
Karen Vernon supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act (S1/A2635) to protect water resources and preserve the Highlands' unique character.
“The lush forest, the clear streams, the abundant wildlife we all cherish are a precious resource to be protected.”transcript p. 25
Martin Cohen — New York-New Jersey Trail Conference
Martin Cohen supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, advocating for a regional plan to ensure fairness in conservation efforts across communities. He emphasizes that water availability, not waste disposal, is the critical factor limiting development.
“I think the idea of a regional plan is appropriate and is the only thing that would work.”transcript p. 45
John Spiech — Private Citizen
John Spiech supports the proposed legislation and urges quick action to protect water resources and prevent further development in the Highlands region.
“I think we have to act quickly.”transcript p. 52
Ross Kushner — Pequannock River Coalition
Ross Kushner supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, believing it will provide necessary tools for preservation. He argues that such legislation, though controversial, will be seen as obviously necessary in the future.
“Now is the moment to save this source of health and wealth. Laws restraining the vandalism should at once be passed.”transcript p. 59
Jon Berry — President; Skylands CLEAN, Inc.
Jon Berry supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act and emphasizes the need for strong state regulations to protect the Highlands. He highlights the urgent local issues of open space protection, development control, and water protection.
“You, no doubt, will be heavily lobbied, I’m sure, to weaken the protections and the planning provisions that were recommended by the task force.”transcript p. 71
Carl Richko — Private Citizen
Carl Richko, former mayor of West Milford, supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act to provide permanent protection for the Highlands and prevent development threats in the core area.
“We need permanent protection for the Highlands, and we should never be under the threat of development in this core area.”transcript p. 89
Timothy Trainor — Private Citizen
Timothy Trainor and Richard Meany both support the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the need for a regional approach to protect the Highlands from inappropriate development.
“I applaud this task force for what you’re trying to do.”transcript p. 95
Jerome Wyckoff —
Jerome Wyckoff supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the benefits of forest preservation including reduced flooding, improved air quality, and increased property values.
“By holding water in wetlands and in the ground, forested land reduces the drainage problems in Highlands’ towns, and reduces flood hazards in adjacent lowlands.”transcript p. 101
Laetitia Munro — Private Citizen
Laetitia Munro, a citizen of West Milford and former zoning board member, urges the passage of the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the need for protection of open space and the challenges faced by towns in resisting development pressures.
“Thank you very much for coming tonight, and I urge you to pass this bill.”transcript p. 102
David Pringle — Campaign Director
David Pringle strongly supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the unprecedented bipartisan process and the need for environmental protection. He urges consideration of all factors, including affordable housing, before weighing the balance of interests.
“I think it’s clear that the overwhelming majority of them are in strong support of this legislation.”transcript p. 103
Betsy Kohn — Chair
Betsy Kohn, Chair of the Sierra Club, North Jersey Group, strongly supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act to protect water resources and preserve the unique character of the Highlands region. She warns against the negative impacts of suburban sprawl and urges legislators to resist attempts to weaken the legislation.
“What’s at stake is protecting our water resources and protecting one of the state’s most beautiful regions, one that retains a sense of place.”transcript p. 104
Michael J. Sebetich — Professor; Biology; William Paterson University, and; Chairperson; Passaic County Open Space and Farmlands Preservation; Trust Fund Committee
Michael J. Sebetich, a professor and chairperson of the Passaic County Open Space and Farmland Preservation Trust Fund Committee, fully supports the recommendations of the Task Force and likely supports the bill. He emphasizes the importance of preserving open spaces in the Highlands, including areas in West Milford, Ringwood, and Bloomingdale.
“We fully support the recommendations of the Task Force.”transcript p. 106
Laura Andersen — Private Citizen
Laura Andersen supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing its comprehensive nature and strong regulations to protect the Highlands region's water supply and open spaces.
“I’m here as a concerned resident, asking you to pass the proposed legislation for the preservation of the Highlands.”transcript p. 106
Dena Mottola — Executive Director; New Jersey Public Interest Research Group; APPENDIX:; Picture; submitted by; Dennis W. Schvejda 1x; Testimony, plus attachment; submitted by; Patty Whitehouse 2x; Letters plus attachments; submitted by; Peter E. Castellano, Esq. 4x; Testimony; submitted by; Ned Clausen 15x; Statement; submitted by; Ross Kushner 18x; Statement; submitted by; Jerry Holt 20x; TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued); APPENDIX (continued): Page; Testimony, plus letter; submitted by; Richard W. Meany Sr. 22x; Testimony; submitted by; Bob Szuszkowski 26x; Witness sign-in sheets; submitted by; Senate Environment Committee, and; Assembly Environment and Solid Waste Committee 32x; lmb: 1-72; rs: 73-113
Dena Mottola, Executive Director of New Jersey PIRG, expressed support for the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act and congratulated local supporters. She also acknowledged additional supporters who were unable to speak.
“I’m doing this on their behalf. And those four people are: John Capozucca, who is a former environmental commissioner in Bloomingdale; Sandy Lawson, who’s with Wanaque Reach; Bob (sic) Weisbecker, who’s an ex- West Milford mayor; and Bob Paulo, who is with a group called Citizens for Public Responsibility.”transcript p. 109
Supported with conditions (19)
Glen Van Olden — Director/District Manager; Hudson-Essex-Passaic Soil Conservation District
Glen Van Olden, Director of the Hudson-Essex-Passaic Soil Conservation District, supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act but requests that the roles of soil conservation districts and county agricultural development boards be maintained in implementing conservation measures and farmland development.
“I ask our Legislators to maintain the rolls of the soil conservation districts in implementing these conservation measures on farmland within the Highlands.”transcript p. 15
Howard Wolfe — Community Builders Association
Howard Wolfe supports the goal of the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act to provide clean water but raises concerns about its provisions. He hopes for improvements to ensure the water supply is protected for current and future residents.
“Please advise why the provisions of the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act did not address the following issues?”transcript p. 18
Wenke Taule — Mayor; Ringwood Borough
Mayor Wenke Taule supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the importance of preserving environmentally sensitive land and protecting drinking water quality and quantity. She requests a freeze on state permits for development applications in the preservation area and financial incentives to stabilize taxes.
“The Ringwood residents understand the importance of preserving the environmentally sensitive land in our Borough.”transcript p. 20
Richard J. Trawinski — Builder/Developer/Engineer; R. J. Trawinski Development Corporation
Richard J. Trawinski supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act but emphasizes the need for just compensation for property owners who will lose their land due to the act.
“My main concern, which I didn’t hear any-- Well, maybe I’ll hear later how you address it -- is the compensation for those who are going to give up their property.”transcript p. 25
Thomas G. Dallessio — New Jersey Director; Regional Plan Association
Thomas G. Dallessio, representing the Regional Plan Association, supports the actions of the task force and finds several aspects of the legislation favorable. He wishes to withhold further comment until a full review of the legislation is completed.
“We wholeheartedly support the actions of the task force.”transcript p. 27
Joseph Maher — County Planner; Atlantic County
Joseph Maher supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act as a statewide initiative but emphasizes the need to learn from past mistakes, particularly with the Pinelands Management Plan. He highlights the importance of equitable solutions and adequate infrastructure to support growth in designated areas.
“I’d like to think we all learn by our mistakes.”transcript p. 32
Vince Polistina —
Vince Polistina supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act but emphasizes the need to avoid past mistakes, particularly in terms of encouraging and agreeing with municipalities on growth. He highlights the challenges faced by growth municipalities and suggests improvements to the plan.
“We didn’t get that. And I would encourage you to do that.”transcript p. 34
Ellis L. Marples — Councilman
Ellis L. Marples supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act for its historic importance in preserving the beauty and water supply of the region. He emphasizes the need for a fair and equitable program to replace funds lost by municipalities.
“'This is historic legislation.'”transcript p. 40
Sue Smith — Councilwoman; Bloomingdale Borough
Sue Smith, Councilwoman of Bloomingdale Borough, strongly supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act (S-1, A-2635) to protect the water supply for over half the state. She urges immediate action, including an emergency freeze on development in the core preservation area.
“Protecting the Highlands is not a new idea that has just popped up recently.”transcript p. 49
Matt Sprung — Vice Chairman; Morris County Planning Board, and; Chairman; Highlands Committee; New Jersey Builders Association
Matt Sprung supports the creation of a regional planning entity in the Highlands to address where people will live while maintaining a healthy environment. He raises concerns about the lack of transparency and the potential misuse of the core preservation area to control growth rather than protect the environment.
“I support regional planning entity of some kind in the Highlands. However, not due to some unsubstantiated threat or disaster, but to find an answer to the question, where will the people live while maintaining a healthy environment?”transcript p. 56
Jeff Tittel — Director
Jeff Tittel, Director of the New Jersey Sierra Club, strongly supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing its critical role in preserving the Highlands' unique ecological and economic values. He highlights the need for regional planning, stricter regulations in core areas, and acquisition based on pre-regulation land prices to protect property values.
“If we don’t save the Highlands, it means we lose our water, we lose a property, we lose the values that we have.”transcript p. 64
Jad Daley — Mid-Atlantic Conservation Director; Appalachian Mountain Club
Jad Daley supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act for its potential to protect outdoor recreation areas and enhance New Jersey's quality of life and economy. He emphasizes the need for additional funding for land preservation to fully realize the benefits of the legislation.
“On behalf of the Appalachian Mountain Club and recreationists across the Garden State, I urge you to pass this important legislation, noting one important issue.”transcript p. 74
Jerry Holt — Former Mayor; Ringwood Borough
Jerry Holt, former Mayor of Ringwood, supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act but emphasizes the need for ongoing compensation for communities affected by land removal from tax rolls. He argues that without such compensation, local taxpayers will face significant financial burdens.
“Shutting down future development in this community will have a disastrous impact on local taxpayers.”transcript p. 78
Joanne Atlas — Council Member; Ringwood Borough
Joanne Atlas supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the importance of preserving the wilderness in Ringwood. She advocates for maintaining the legal shield in the legislation and suggests a water surcharge as a fair alternative to property tax changes.
“'I thank you for recognizing that. Last year, we nearly lost one of our treasurers, West Brook Mountain.'”transcript p. 81
Joy Farber — Chair
Joy Farber supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, emphasizing the need for a regional planning entity and compensation for local communities. She commends the balance struck by the legislation and encourages its progression with fairness and reasonability.
“'It makes sense to protect, with a regional planning entity, our water. And it also makes sense to have a temporary, short-term moratorium on development while that regional planning entity is going to be in place.'”transcript p. 82
Doris Aaronson —
Doris Aaronson supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act but emphasizes the need for a regional plan to control planning and land use, and more stringent permit requirements and enforcement procedures by the DEP to protect water and natural resources.
“We certainly need a regional plan to control planning and land use, because home rule in West Milford and other Highlands towns simply does not work to protect the water in the Highlands -- for half of the water supply of New Jersey.”transcript p. 85
Celeste Byrne — Member; West Milford Open Space Advisory Committee, and
Celeste Byrne supports the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act but emphasizes the need to bypass home rule and provide a funding mechanism for cash-starved communities.
“Words will not protect your water, words will not save your trees, words will not bring back the habitat of our wildlife.”transcript p. 91
Ann Benedetto — President; Snake Den Community Road Association
Ann Benedetto, president of a local Ringwood road association, emphasizes the necessity of protecting the water supply and suggests a State or tri-state lottery to raise revenues for the Highlands.
“Protection of our water supply is not an option, it’s a necessity.”transcript p. 94
Bob Szuszkowski — Private Citizen
Bob Szuszkowski, a former West Milford town councilman and current educator, urges the passage of the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act to protect undeveloped land in the Highlands from degradation and sprawl. He emphasizes the importance of stable funding to offset any loss of tax revenue for permanently protected lands.
“I urge you to pass the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act to help protect the undeveloped land in the Highlands from the effects of further degradation, sprawl, and destruction.”transcript p. 97
Opposed the bill (9)
Scott Heck — Councilman; Ringwood Borough
Scott Heck, a Councilman from Ringwood, opposes the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act due to concerns about the financial burden on Ringwood residents and the impact on local businesses and the economy.
“In your bill, home rule seems to be a thing of the past, and you’re asking us to give up the say of what goes on in our community.”transcript p. 21
Thomas Carroll — Borough Administrator; Wanaque Borough
Thomas Carroll opposes the current form of the legislation due to practical concerns about its impact on ongoing municipal projects and the loss of home rule. He suggests exempting municipal projects from the moratorium and emphasizes the need for municipal input and additional revenues for hosting water resources.
“Does that project, now, get stopped? We do road reconstruction projects, under the State Transportation Trust Fund; those projects are more than two acres. Do those all get stopped, now, for 18 months?”transcript p. 28
Frank Sutton — Deputy Mayor; Egg Harbor Township
Frank Sutton, Deputy Mayor of Egg Harbor Township, opposes the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act due to concerns about the impact of mandated growth on infrastructure and traffic, and the lack of state funding for stormwater management and other infrastructure needs.
“We’re the fastest, largest growing. We receive none.”transcript p. 38
Dennis Kirwan — Councilman; West Milford Township
Dennis Kirwan, Councilman of West Milford Township, opposes the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act due to concerns about loss of home rule, insufficient funding mechanisms, and potential negative impacts on local finances and development.
“The things I want to get through is, we are proud of the fact that we provide clean drinking water. We have, I think, four of the reservoirs in our township alone.”transcript p. 41
Ned Clausen — Private Citizen
Ned Clausen opposes the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, arguing that it places an additional financial burden on already stressed municipalities and may not significantly improve water quality.
“You don’t take on additional burden if your burden is already more than you can handle.”transcript p. 46
Joseph Pacio — Private Citizen
Joseph Pacio, a Ringwood taxpayer, opposes the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act due to perceived inequities in water rates and tax burdens between Ringwood and other towns. He demands immediate tax relief and a fairer distribution of costs for water usage.
“It’s very nice to preserve the land, and 70 percent of our land is owned by the State and the Reservoir, but we can’t afford it up here anymore.”transcript p. 51
Doris Osterhoust — Private Citizen
Doris Osterhoust opposes the Highlands Task Force plan, comparing it to historical land confiscations by Newark and advocating for true home rule for West Milford. She suggests fighting the plan through prayer and community action rather than weapons.
“This Highlands Task Force plan is not new. It is almost an exact carbon copy from the 1900s when Newark came in our vicinity and condemned, or paid a nominal fee for land they wanted here in West Milford.”transcript p. 68
Steve Caporaso — Private Citizen
Steve Caporaso, a self-employed home builder, opposes the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act due to its lack of balance between environmental protection and housing needs. He fears the bill will prevent affordable housing and economic development in the area.
“What this bill lacks is balance.”transcript p. 73
Ihor Mulyk — Private Citizen
Ihor Mulyk opposes the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act, arguing that local residents should have the right to decide how their lands are used and questioning why they should bear the financial burden for protecting water they don't use.
“Over 12,000 Ringwood residents -- 40 to 45 percent of them may be children -- are bearing the burden of protecting the water for over two million users, yet, we do not even use any of the water from the Wanaque Reservoir ourselves.”transcript p. 93